Logo for Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Senior Casualty Claim Representative

Role overview

Summary

This role is for a Senior Casualty Claim Representative at Hastings Insurance, focusing on resolving casualty claims. You will be a key partner to customers and the agency force, ensuring timely service and fair outcomes while contributing to effective claims handling.

Qualifications

  • 5+ years of progressively responsible experience handling casualty claims, ideally in a commercial lines setting.
  • Excellent verbal and written communication skills.
  • Demonstrated critical thinking, sound judgment, and customer service orientation.
  • Preferred: Bachelor’s degree preferred; equivalent insurance education and experience may be considered.
  • Preferred: Industry designations such as AIC, SCLA, or CPCU (or active progress toward one).

Responsibilities

  • Manage a personal caseload of casualty claims within company policy and legal guidelines.
  • Communicate regularly with insureds, claimants, agents, and vendors to guide the claim resolution process.
  • Investigate, evaluate, and settle claims promptly and fairly.
  • Identify and pursue salvage and subrogation opportunities to minimize loss.

Key facts

Hard skills

Key skills for this role

Other skills

  • Investigation
  • Communication
  • Critical Thinking
  • Customer Service

About the company

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company logo

Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

  • Insurance
  • SME
  • 201–500
Hastings Mutual Insurance Company is an award winning, regional property/casualty insurance company with a six-state, Midwest marketing territory. Our home office is located in Hastings, Michigan. For over 130 years, Hastings Mutual has had an outstanding reputation based on excellent customer service and top quality insurance products, backed by sound fiscal responsibility. We value our relationships with our independent agents who are demonstrated experts in their field. Hastings Mutual is a regional employer of choice and has been named to the 101 Best and Brightest Companies to Work for in West Michigan each year since 2011. For more information, find us on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/HastingsMutual.

Your match analysis

See how your profile stacks up against this role.

We compared the job requirements to your profile to show where you're strong and where you fall short.

Job description

Make your mark as a trusted expert in resolving casualty claims.

Hastings Insurance is seeking a Senior Casualty Claim Representative to join its Casualty Claim team. The individual in this role will investigate, evaluates, and resolve routine to moderate casualty claims while ensuring timely service and fair outcomes for all parties involved. This role is central to our commitment to responsive, effective claims handling and serves as a key partner to our customers and agency force.

What You’ll Do:

  • Manage a personal caseload of casualty claims within company policy and legal guidelines.
  • Communicate regularly with insureds, claimants, agents, and vendors to guide the claim resolution process.
  • Apply appropriate coverage analysis, documenting rationale and engaging leadership as needed.
  • Investigate, evaluate, and settle claims promptly and fairly.
  • Identify and pursue salvage and subrogation opportunities to minimize loss.
  • Use authorized tools and systems to document, estimate, and support claim decisions.
  • Establish and maintain accurate case reserves based on current knowledge and anticipated outcomes.
  • Monitor vendor services to ensure only necessary and cost-effective work is performed.
  • Support less experienced claims staff with technical guidance as appropriate.
  • Share relevant claim insights with internal partners (e.g., Underwriting, Loss Control).
  • Participate in departmental projects and serve on committees or special assignments as needed.

What You’ll Bring:

  • 5+ years of progressively responsible experience handling casualty claims, ideally in a commercial lines setting.
  • Bachelor’s degree preferred; equivalent insurance education and experience may be considered.
  • Industry designations such as AIC, SCLA, or CPCU (or active progress toward one).
  • Excellent verbal and written communication skills.
  • Demonstrated critical thinking, sound judgment, and customer service orientation.
  • Ability to manage conflict, navigate sensitive situations, and work independently.
  • Proficiency in claims systems and documentation tools.
  • Commitment to continuous improvement and professional development.

Location & Schedule:

This is a full-time salaried position, working a schedule of Monday - Friday, 8:00 am - 4:30 pm at our Hastings, Michigan headquarters in a hybrid work format. However, consideration may be given to candidates who reside in one of our five coverage states (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, Wisconsin). 

About Hastings Insurance:

For more than 135 years, Hastings Insurance has helped individuals, families, and businesses protect what matters most. As a trusted partner to independent agents and policyholders, we've earned a reputation for financial strength, exceptional service, and long-term stability, including an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from A.M. Best.

While we're proud of our history, we're equally focused on the future. We're investing in technology, strengthening partnerships with independent agents, and continuously evolving our products and services to meet the changing needs of our customers.

Just as importantly, we're investing in our people. Employees enjoy a collaborative, down-to-earth culture where initiative is valued, growth is encouraged, and good work is recognized. We offer competitive pay and benefits, including a 401(k) with company matching contributions, generous paid time off, tuition and professional development assistance, and company performance-based incentive compensation opportunities.

Our Organizational Commitment:

At Hastings Insurance, we believe our people are our greatest strength. We foster a workplace where employees are treated with respect, supported in their growth, and empowered to contribute. We know that diverse perspectives lead to stronger collaboration, better decisions, and better outcomes for our customers and communities.

We are proud to be an equal opportunity employer. Employment decisions are based on business needs, job requirements, and individual qualifications, without regard to any legally protected characteristic.

If you require a reasonable accommodation during the application or interview process, please contact our Talent Acquisition team at 800-442-8277.

Related jobs

See all jobs

Other jobs at Hastings Mutual Insurance Company